Paul H. Byerly
Elsewhere we discuss why it is wrong to refuse sex, but what do you do if your spouse chooses to say no? We get several private letters a month from men and women living in a sexless or near sexless marriages against their will. These individuals are demographically diverse - they are young, middle aged and senior, some have kids, some don't; the problem may have existed all along, may have gradually gotten worse, or may have occurred very suddenly. What these folks do have in common is frustration, pain, no idea what to do, and most often a spouse who refuses to discuss the issue or even admit there is a problem. It is our prayer that the following information will help those in this situation find a starting place for change.
The first thing to do is to try to determine the reason your spouse is refusing sex. This is difficult as there are a variety of sexual and non-sexual issues that can cause sexual refusal. It's also possible that previous sexual behaviour was mostly or completely an act, meaning what appears to be a sudden problem may have always existed, and was only hidden before. The problem can be a combination of things, and a person who tends towards negative feelings about sex may only need a very small "push" to stop wanting to have sex. It is also possible that the original trigger issue has ended, and the non-sexual behaviour remains. Additionally, a lack of willingness to have sex does not always mean a lack of sex drive. Finally, the onset of the problem and the change in sexual behaviour can be separated by months or years; don’t assume the clue to a sexual change can be found in the recent past.
Some people seem to have a never-ending supply of "good reasons" for saying no. Individually each reason seems fair, but taken as a whole it's obvious something is wrong. When a constant stream of reasons for not having sex continues for very long, there is some underlying reason for the lack of sex; the reasons given are merely convenient or concocted excuses that hide the real problem. We make time and energy for the things that are most important to us, so when we are routinely too busy or too tired for something it suggests that the real issue is more about priorities than time.
Use the following list to see if you can identify problem areas that may be causing or aggravating anti-sex feelings.
Sometimes sexual refusal is primarily about selfishness. Any of the things above may be a factor, but the underlying issue is simple selfishness - “I don't want to, and what I want is more important to me than what you want” - or what God wants. This kind of behaviour is rarely limited to sexuality - selfish people are selfish across the spectrum. If you think you see selfishness only in how your spouse approaches sex, rethink; there is probably more to it. That said, the view of sexuality our society (and sadly much of the church) has makes it easy to justify sexual selfishness. This means sexual selfishness may show up in someone who is too embarrassed to be openly selfish in other areas.
If you identify a problem, what then? Some of the above are things that you, the spouse, have some power to affect - especially relationship issues. Others are things you may be able to improve by working with your spouse, such as better use of time, cutting back on some activities or getting medical help. However, many of these issues are out of your control.
Getting Help: If the issue(s) are out of your control, they will only be resolved if you can persuade your spouse to seek help or make changes. A minister or counsellor can be a big help, if you can get your spouse to go. You may have a better chance to get them to go for an underlying non-sexual issue than for the sexual problem itself; if you have a good idea about the cause of the problem, work towards dealing with that before addressing the sexual issue. If your spouse won’t go with you for help, go alone. A good counsellor can help you sort things out, help you make changes in you that may precipitate changes in your spouse, and offer some ideas on how to better communicate about the issue with your spouse.
Self Help: Unless the situation is new and/or minor, you really need some good third party help. If you think the problem is not yet critical, if your spouse refuses to go with you, or if you can’t find free help and really can’t afford to pay for help, we suggest the following books.
Got feelings?: If you are a man, it may help to change how you talk about your sexual needs. If a woman hears “I’m horny, do something about it” she is not likely to feel sympathetic. Because of male/female differences, a wife may hear this even though her husband is neither saying nor means that. Due to gender differences, she may feel he is all about, and only about the physical part of sex. It helps is she can hear and understand that he wants and needs sex for emotional and relational reasons. She needs to know that having sex makes her husband feel loved, while hearing “no” to sex makes him feel unloved. When sex becomes about more than bodies, when it becomes a thing of feelings, she is more likely to see sex as important.
Trying to get change: Some sexually refusing spouses also refuse to talk about the situation or admit there is a problem. In this situation, the alternatives are limited. It seems the only three choices are to give up and live with it, divorce, or push the matter - possibly to the point of crisis. Human nature is to resist change in general, and change we don't want in particular. Change happens when 1) the change seems advantageous 2) the individual is motivated to do what is right or 3) when not changing is more uncomfortable changing.
Why change would be good: The gentle, loving approach is to point out the good that would come from a change in your sex life. This is about the two of you as a couple, rather than your needs. Sex has many positive health benefits (a future article) as well as being very good for the marriage relationship. Saying things like “I want a great sex life for both of us” and asking how you can help are good ways to approach this option.
It’s the right thing to do: If your spouse has integrity, and/or if they are all about being right with God, you may be able to persuade them to change because it’s the right thing to do. However, such a change is unlikely to hold up if sex remains difficult or unfulfilling. Having more sex may bring bout a change, but if it does not be sure to work on the underlying issues. Our articles Sexual Responsibility: A Look at 1 Corinthians 7 and Sexual Stewardship may be of some help if you take this option. You will also want to explain to your spouse, calmly and loving, what sex with them means to you.
Precipitating a Crisis/Ultimatums: Some spouses have saved their sex life (and marriage) by saying, "you deal with this or _____." If the marriage is important to the refusing spouse, such an ultimatum may cause them to seek help or attempt to change. On the other hand, if the marriage is not important, or the reason they are avoiding sex is more important than the marriage or just too painful, an ultimatum can end the marriage. This is a last ditch effort and you should only resort to this after trying everything else, and praying a great deal. Do not make an ultimatum you don’t mean – if you won’t leave, or if you know it’s not okay with God for you to leave, then don’t say you will leave. If you can’t keep sharing a bed without sex, then tell your spouse that. If you are tired of pretending in front of others, explain what will happen if your spouse does nothing.
In the final analysis, a marriage crippled by sexual refusal is a difficult issue with no easy or sure-fire answers. What works for one couple will not work for another. Some couples have gone so long that recovery would be a true miracle, and many couples never accomplish anything more than partial improvement. Change takes time, commitment, and a lot of prayer and energy. The one sure thing about sexual refusal, as with most problems, is that it only gets worse when it's ignored.
Kate and Brad Aldrich have some excellent articles about this issue on their One Flesh Marriage blog. Check out:
Image Credits in order shown: © Wernerheiber | dreamstime.com © Chrishowey | dreamstime.com
© Oleg Golovnev | Dreamstime.com © Norebbo | Dreamstime.com